Sun07312011

Last update08:52:53 PM

Back More Sports News Opinion Give Me A Ring! 'Bama Says "No"

Give Me A Ring! 'Bama Says "No"

Written by Benjamin Dial
User Rating: / 0
PoorBest 

Cheerleading is not a sport.

That’s right. I said it, and I’ll say it again. Cheerleading is not a sport. If you don’t believe me, ask the NCAA or the University of Alabama. They will tell you exactly the same thing.

In fact, both already have. Earlier in the month, the Crimson Tide cheerleading squad won the national championship by upsetting Kentucky. I know, I know. Just another fall sport that the SEC seems to dominate.

But the boys and gals that led the ‘Bama faithful in Roll Tide cheers won’t be receiving championship rings despite the policy of the University of Alabama to provide them after one of their own wins a national championship. Their reason was quite simple. Cheerleading is not a sport.

Well, it was a little more politically correct than that. They said it wasn’t an NCAA officially sanctioned sport. So, in reality, the NCAA says it isn’t a sport and the University of Alabama agrees with that assessment.

So do I.

What is cheerleading, really? It’s dancing and yelling so far as I can tell. Granted, it takes a lot of athletic ability to jump backwards and sideways and to flip around hither and thither. No doubt, there are countless hours of choreographing and practicing. I’m sure they hit the weights and train like athletes of officially sanctioned NCAA sports.

And, hey, they are certainly athletic. They compete. I’ll give them that. They just don’t compete in a sport.

A sport is something pure, something with a definitive scoring method. In football, you get six points if the ball crosses your opponent’s goal line if one of your players is in control of the football. You get another point if you kick it through the uprights after the touchdown. If you can’t score a touchdown, but kick it through the uprights, you still get three points. These rules are set in stone. You don’t get extra points for being pretty or points deducted because the form was less than the perfect soccer style kicking technique.

Before people starting labeling me as a sexist because cheerleading is dominated by females (even though most college squads have a large contingent of males also), let me set the record straight. I’m an equal opportunity hater.

Cheerleading, gymnastics, figure skating, diving, and the majority of X Games events are not sports in my opinion. If it requires judges to dictate the score rather than an unbiased, by-golly point scoring method, it just isn’t a real sport. It’s art that is judged.

This distinction of sport and arts such as gymnastics is not received very well among the fancy dance community. Apparently, they don’t like to be seen as something as elegant as art. It’s sport or bust. Well, I don’t agree.

For me to consider something a sport, the objective needs to be more important than the subjective. Woe be the day that a slam dunk gets an extra two tenths of a point because it was a reverse jam or a three point basket only gets 2.5 because the shot was a little flat or drew some iron before sliding through the net.

That isn’t to say that some sports don’t have subjective elements. What exactly constitutes pass interference anyway? Balls and strikes are even named “judgment calls” by the rule book. Don’t get me started on continuation in the NBA.

And yes, I understand that many boxing matches and mixed martial arts fights have ended going to the judges’ scorecard. And at that point, the winner, especially in MMA, is determined by very subjective terms. But you know what? Both boxing and MMA have a very objective way to finish before it goes to the judges. Someone can quit or someone can be separated from their consciousness, otherwise known as knocked out.

In a real sport, the objective must take precedence over the subjective. NASCAR is much more of a sport than gymnastics because the scoring is clear. Lead laps, get points. Finish near the top, earn a bunch of points. Golf is the most objective sport of all. Par is four. Make it in three, good for you. Make it in five, the ugly square goes on the scorecard.

Is this the way it is in cheerleading or gymnastics? No way. Someone can land a sideways salto (that would be a sideways somersault), but if the right pinky toe is not exactly 40 degrees south by southwest, it’s a deduction. That’s probably somewhat of an exaggeration, but it’s not the same as scoring a goal in hockey which always counts exactly the same no matter how ugly or pretty the shot that sent the puck into the net happens to look.

Again, I’m not at all saying that gymnasts and cheerleaders aren’t athletic. They certainly are. I would never even attempt to do the crazy stuff they do. It’s dangerous, and I would likely break my neck. I wouldn’t go snorkeling with the sharks either. That requires some athletic ability, some risk, and is a bit crazy. Still not a sport.

That being said, the University of Alabama needs to award these hard working student athl...student competitors with national championship rings. They competed in an artistic showdown with short skirts and letter signs. They made their most geometrically perfect pyramids and yelled “Roll Tide” in perfect unison.

So, no. It’s not a sport, but I’m willing to give them their due.

Comments

0 Carson Faricloth 2011-07-01 11:59 #27
Okay cheerleading isn't a sport? Its not just a bunch of girls dancing around in a skirt and yelling! Its more than that! Why would they give out rings at the Cheerleading World Championships? Exactly! Because cheerleading is a sport to them. And if it's not a sport why would they show it on ESPN?
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-02-02 16:26 #26
I understand that it fits the dictionary description of what a sport is. It's hard for me to consider something a sport where you don't compete directly against someone or something else. Everyone does an independent routine and they get judged.
Even in bowling you take turns frame by frame against your opponent.
Cheerleading, gymnastics, diving, figure skating, etc, are physical arts that are judged.
Quote
-1 Benjamin Dial 2011-02-02 16:26 #25
I understand that it fits the dictionary description of what a sport is. It's hard for me to consider something a sport where you don't compete directly against someone or something else. Everyone does an independent routine and they get judged.
Even in bowling you take turns frame by frame against your opponent.
Cheerleading, gymnastics, diving, figure skating, etc, are physical arts that are judged.
Quote
0 Guest 2011-02-02 07:22 #24
Sure "cheerleading" is a sport. Not a sport I particularly like, or would ever really participate in, however at the highest level of competition it can be best described as coordinated floor routines from gymnastics. The problem is the connection to male-spectator sport that no longer makes sense, and is damn near insulting to the women involved. Really, how many of you sitting in a 60,000 capacity stadium can even point out where the cheer squad is among the mess on the sidelines? Just let it go and be its own thing, I don't need it as other stuff.

Now on to Ben's assertion that it is not a sport based on its scoring methods. There are plenty of sports judged, some strikingly similar. Drill and ceremony teams in the military, floor routines of a gymnast, diving, martial arts forms competition.

Like Will mentioned, the stuff on the sidelines is not a sport, it is an exhibition of sport.
Quote
+1 Guest 2011-02-02 07:22 #23
Sure "cheerleading" is a sport. Not a sport I particularly like, or would ever really participate in, however at the highest level of competition it can be best described as coordinated floor routines from gymnastics. The problem is the connection to male-spectator sport that no longer makes sense, and is damn near insulting to the women involved. Really, how many of you sitting in a 60,000 capacity stadium can even point out where the cheer squad is among the mess on the sidelines? Just let it go and be its own thing, I don't need it as other stuff.

Now on to Ben's assertion that it is not a sport based on its scoring methods. There are plenty of sports judged, some strikingly similar. Drill and ceremony teams in the military, floor routines of a gymnast, diving, martial arts forms competition.

Like Will mentioned, the stuff on the sidelines is not a sport, it is an exhibition of sport.
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-31 20:23 #22
Quoting William Bryhn:
Quoting Ben Dial:
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.



Well thats cool then. It's simply "YOUR OPINION".

IMO MMA and Boxing aren't sports either. Just two idiots beating each other to a pulp.


lol
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-31 20:23 #21
Quoting William Bryhn:
Quoting Ben Dial:
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.



Well thats cool then. It's simply "YOUR OPINION".

IMO MMA and Boxing aren't sports either. Just two idiots beating each other to a pulp.


lol
Quote
0 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 15:54 #20
Quoting Ben Dial:
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.



Well thats cool then. It's simply "YOUR OPINION".

IMO MMA and Boxing aren't sports either. Just two idiots beating each other to a pulp.
Quote
+1 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 15:54 #19
Quoting Ben Dial:
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.



Well thats cool then. It's simply "YOUR OPINION".

IMO MMA and Boxing aren't sports either. Just two idiots beating each other to a pulp.
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 15:31 #18
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.
Quote
-1 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 15:31 #17
By that same definition, darts and croquet are both sports and not games.

Webster's definition of "sport" is a horrible definition. That's why I use my own. In fact, in the article, I said, "For me to consider something a sport..."

So really, by my own admission as written in the article, cheerleading is not a sport.
Quote
0 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 14:39 #16
Quoting Ben Dial:
Quoting William Bryhn:
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.

I don't think either of it is a sport. Anything where the sole criteria of picking a winner (figure skating, diving, gymnastics, cheerleading, is not a true sport in my opinion. It's art that is judged.



Thats your definition Dial, unfortunately the Olympics disagree with you on figure skating, diving & gymnastics.

sport (spôrt, sprt)
n.
1.
a. Physical activity that is governed by a set of rules or customs and often engaged in competitively.

Thats the "true" definition of sport Ben. By your own admission in this article, competitive cheerleading would definitely qualify.
Quote
+2 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 14:39 #15
Quoting Ben Dial:
Quoting William Bryhn:
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.

I don't think either of it is a sport. Anything where the sole criteria of picking a winner (figure skating, diving, gymnastics, cheerleading, is not a true sport in my opinion. It's art that is judged.



Thats your definition Dial, unfortunately the Olympics disagree with you on figure skating, diving & gymnastics.

sport (spôrt, sprt)
n.
1.
a. Physical activity that is governed by a set of rules or customs and often engaged in competitively.

Thats the "true" definition of sport Ben. By your own admission in this article, competitive cheerleading would definitely qualify.
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 14:00 #14
Quoting William Bryhn:
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.

I don't think either of it is a sport. Anything where the sole criteria of picking a winner (figure skating, diving, gymnastics, cheerleading, is not a true sport in my opinion. It's art that is judged.
Quote
-1 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 14:00 #13
Quoting William Bryhn:
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.

I don't think either of it is a sport. Anything where the sole criteria of picking a winner (figure skating, diving, gymnastics, cheerleading, is not a true sport in my opinion. It's art that is judged.
Quote
0 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 13:40 #12
PS Ben, I sent this article to my friend who is a National Champion in cheerleading (2008) to see what she thinks of this.

I hope she comments
Quote
0 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 13:40 #11
PS Ben, I sent this article to my friend who is a National Champion in cheerleading (2008) to see what she thinks of this.

I hope she comments
Quote
0 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 13:25 #10
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.
Quote
+2 William Bryhn 2011-01-30 13:25 #9
The cheerleading on the sidelines of football/basketball games a sport? No

The competitive cheerleading that goes on at competitions? I think it is a sport.
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 04:25 #8
That they do, but the very fact that the objective means of winning overrules what the judges say makes it a sport.
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 04:25 #7
That they do, but the very fact that the objective means of winning overrules what the judges say makes it a sport.
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-30 03:15 #6
Quoting Ben Dial:
The difference with boxing and MMA is that the objective is always more important than the subjective. If a guy gets knocked out or submitted, it doesn't matter what the judges think.


Thats true that they have that ultimatum way of finishing it and "not leaving it in the judges hands". But I would bet that over half of all fights go to the judges and their scorecards.
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-30 03:15 #5
Quoting Ben Dial:
The difference with boxing and MMA is that the objective is always more important than the subjective. If a guy gets knocked out or submitted, it doesn't matter what the judges think.


Thats true that they have that ultimatum way of finishing it and "not leaving it in the judges hands". But I would bet that over half of all fights go to the judges and their scorecards.
Quote
0 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 02:13 #4
The difference with boxing and MMA is that the objective is always more important than the subjective. If a guy gets knocked out or submitted, it doesn't matter what the judges think.
Quote
+1 Benjamin Dial 2011-01-30 02:13 #3
The difference with boxing and MMA is that the objective is always more important than the subjective. If a guy gets knocked out or submitted, it doesn't matter what the judges think.
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-30 02:02 #2
I think if you call any sport that has scores/judging a sport, like it or not, competitive cheerleading has to be considered one. Diving, figure skating, gymnastics (arguably the most popular sport in the olympics) and even MMA or boxing are judged if you don't finish the fight. We may have different levels of how highly regarded a sport is, but IMO any athletic competition can be under the term "sport".
Quote
0 Guest 2011-01-30 02:02 #1
I think if you call any sport that has scores/judging a sport, like it or not, competitive cheerleading has to be considered one. Diving, figure skating, gymnastics (arguably the most popular sport in the olympics) and even MMA or boxing are judged if you don't finish the fight. We may have different levels of how highly regarded a sport is, but IMO any athletic competition can be under the term "sport".
Quote

Add comment


All Time Popular

Auburn: New "Thug U"

Must Read - Forum

NBA Finals